“10/10” treat? Sam’s Club shoppers rave about new bakery favorite
- Replies 1
Sam’s Club has a new bakery drop that’s creating serious buzz, especially among fans of Starbucks’ iconic cake pops.
The warehouse retailer recently launched Member’s Mark Birthday Cake and Cookies ‘N Creme Cake Pops—and shoppers are calling them a “10/10.”
At $1.36 per pop, they’re not just cute—they’re a budget-friendly answer to the $3.25 Starbucks version.
Whether you're stocking up for a party or stashing sweets in the freezer, the value here is hard to beat.
Sam’s Club didn’t just mimic Starbucks—they added their own spin. The Birthday Cake Pop comes wrapped in creamy white chocolate and rainbow sprinkles, with a soft vanilla cake center that channels classic birthday vibes.
For chocolate lovers, the Cookies ‘N Creme version is coated entirely in cookie crumbs—going far beyond Starbucks’ light dusting. Both options are rich, dense, and designed to hit that nostalgic sweet spot.
One of the most common complaints with store-bought cake pops? They’re either too dry or too crumbly.
But Instagram reviewer @samsclubfoodreviews rated both of Sam’s Club’s versions a full 10/10, calling the texture “dense, chewy, and soft in the center.”
Also read: You’re overpaying for Starbucks—Walmart’s cheaper copycat is winning over fans
This level of execution puts them in bakery-quality territory—not your average bulk-store dessert. Starbucks cake pops may look innocent at the register, but at $3.25 each, the cost adds up quickly.
Sam’s Club sells a 14-pack for $18.98, working out to just $1.36 per pop. That’s a savings of nearly $2 per treat—or $30 when buying in bulk. It’s the same flavor, more fun, and a lot more bang for your buck.
Need a quick party snack or a sugar fix for later? These pops are easy to freeze and even easier to serve. Just thaw a few minutes before eating and enjoy—no baking, no cleanup.
Also read: Don’t miss out! Discover the 3 irresistible Ben & Jerry’s flavors everyone’s talking about (Available for a limited time!)
They’re also great as DIY party favors or small gifts when wrapped in cellophane and ribbon. As with most of Sam’s Club’s seasonal bakery items, these cake pops won’t be around forever.
Early shoppers are already calling them one of the best bakery finds of the summer. If you want to see what the hype is about, don’t wait too long. These treats may be gone before your next grocery run.
Read next: Dunkin’s new summer lineup includes ice cream-inspired drinks, fun bites, and sweet surprises
Have you gotten your hands on Sam’s Club’s new cake pops? Are they really better than Starbucks—or just a good dupe? What’s your go-to way to serve them (or stash them)? Drop your thoughts in the comments and let fellow readers know if these are worth a trip to the bakery aisle.
The warehouse retailer recently launched Member’s Mark Birthday Cake and Cookies ‘N Creme Cake Pops—and shoppers are calling them a “10/10.”
At $1.36 per pop, they’re not just cute—they’re a budget-friendly answer to the $3.25 Starbucks version.
Whether you're stocking up for a party or stashing sweets in the freezer, the value here is hard to beat.
Sam’s Club didn’t just mimic Starbucks—they added their own spin. The Birthday Cake Pop comes wrapped in creamy white chocolate and rainbow sprinkles, with a soft vanilla cake center that channels classic birthday vibes.
For chocolate lovers, the Cookies ‘N Creme version is coated entirely in cookie crumbs—going far beyond Starbucks’ light dusting. Both options are rich, dense, and designed to hit that nostalgic sweet spot.
One of the most common complaints with store-bought cake pops? They’re either too dry or too crumbly.
But Instagram reviewer @samsclubfoodreviews rated both of Sam’s Club’s versions a full 10/10, calling the texture “dense, chewy, and soft in the center.”
Also read: You’re overpaying for Starbucks—Walmart’s cheaper copycat is winning over fans
This level of execution puts them in bakery-quality territory—not your average bulk-store dessert. Starbucks cake pops may look innocent at the register, but at $3.25 each, the cost adds up quickly.
Sam’s Club sells a 14-pack for $18.98, working out to just $1.36 per pop. That’s a savings of nearly $2 per treat—or $30 when buying in bulk. It’s the same flavor, more fun, and a lot more bang for your buck.
Need a quick party snack or a sugar fix for later? These pops are easy to freeze and even easier to serve. Just thaw a few minutes before eating and enjoy—no baking, no cleanup.
Also read: Don’t miss out! Discover the 3 irresistible Ben & Jerry’s flavors everyone’s talking about (Available for a limited time!)
They’re also great as DIY party favors or small gifts when wrapped in cellophane and ribbon. As with most of Sam’s Club’s seasonal bakery items, these cake pops won’t be around forever.
Early shoppers are already calling them one of the best bakery finds of the summer. If you want to see what the hype is about, don’t wait too long. These treats may be gone before your next grocery run.
Read next: Dunkin’s new summer lineup includes ice cream-inspired drinks, fun bites, and sweet surprises
