Back by popular demand: Costco’s famous ice cream sandwich gets a flavor makeover
- Replies 0
If you’ve ever found yourself wandering the frozen aisles of Costco, searching for that perfect sweet treat to cap off a summer barbecue or simply to enjoy on a lazy afternoon, you’re not alone.
For many atThe GrayVine, the hunt for the ultimate ice cream sandwich is a time-honored tradition—one that brings back memories of childhood summers, sticky fingers, and the simple joy of a cold dessert on a hot day.
Well, get ready to relive those memories and make some new ones, because the cult-favorite ice cream sandwiches are back at Costco—and this time, they’re sporting a brand-new, mouthwatering flavor that’s already causing a frenzy.
A Sweet Return: Nightingale’s Strawberry Shortcake Sensation
Last year, Nightingale’s Cookie Monster ice cream sandwiches took Costco by storm, selling out in a matter of days.
Fans raved about the creamy vanilla ice cream, the generous cookie crumb swirls, and the chewy chocolate chip cookies that held it all together.
If you missed out, you weren’t alone—these treats became the stuff of legend, with social media buzzing about their sudden disappearance from shelves.
Now, just in time for summer, Nightingale is back with a fresh twist: Strawberry Shortcake.
Imagine this—luscious, creamy strawberry ice cream (made with real berries!) sandwiched between two soft, brown sugar cookies. It’s a nostalgic nod to the classic dessert, but with a gourmet upgrade that only Nightingale can deliver.
What Makes Nightingale So Special?
Let’s be honest: the freezer aisle is packed with ice cream sandwiches, but Nightingale stands out for a reason. Here’s why these treats have earned their cult status:
A Deal That’s Hard to Beat
Let’s talk numbers. At $19.99 for a box of 18, you’re looking at just over a dollar per sandwich.
Compare that to the four-packs sold at other retailers for $7–$9, and it’s clear: Costco is the place to stock up. (And let’s be honest, when it comes to ice cream sandwiches, more is always better.)
Where Can You Find Them?
Here’s the catch—these Strawberry Shortcake sandwiches are currently only available at Costco locations in the Northeast, from Virginia to Maine.
If you’re lucky enough to live in this region, consider this your sign to make a Costco run ASAP.
Also read: The $6 find shoppers say they could eat by the spoonful—and it’s back on shelves
For everyone else, Nightingale is encouraging fans to tag their local Costco on social media and demand these treats make their way nationwide. Power to the people!
Not in the Northeast? Don’t despair. Nightingale’s website can help you track down their other flavors—like Miso Churro, Banana Pudding, Key Lime Pie, and Chocolate French Toast—at retailers near you.
And who knows? With enough demand, maybe Strawberry Shortcake will make a national debut.
Source: @checkoutvick / Tiktok.
What the Fans Are Saying
The buzz is real. One social media reviewer gave the new Strawberry Shortcake sandwiches a perfect “10 out of 10,” raving about the soft, chewy cookies and the fresh, fruity ice cream.
Online reviews echo the sentiment—these aren’t your average ice cream sandwiches. They’re a step above, and the perfect way to treat yourself (or your grandkids) this summer.
Read next: What’s back at Trader Joe’s this summer? Limited-time treats await
Have you tried Nightingale’s new Strawberry Shortcake ice cream sandwiches? Are you a die-hard fan of the Cookie Monster flavor, or do you have another favorite? Maybe you have a cherished memory of ice cream sandwiches from your own childhood—or a secret tip for making them even better.
We want to hear from you! Share your thoughts, reviews, and ice cream sandwich stories in the comments below!
For many atThe GrayVine, the hunt for the ultimate ice cream sandwich is a time-honored tradition—one that brings back memories of childhood summers, sticky fingers, and the simple joy of a cold dessert on a hot day.
Well, get ready to relive those memories and make some new ones, because the cult-favorite ice cream sandwiches are back at Costco—and this time, they’re sporting a brand-new, mouthwatering flavor that’s already causing a frenzy.
A Sweet Return: Nightingale’s Strawberry Shortcake Sensation
Last year, Nightingale’s Cookie Monster ice cream sandwiches took Costco by storm, selling out in a matter of days.
Fans raved about the creamy vanilla ice cream, the generous cookie crumb swirls, and the chewy chocolate chip cookies that held it all together.
If you missed out, you weren’t alone—these treats became the stuff of legend, with social media buzzing about their sudden disappearance from shelves.
Now, just in time for summer, Nightingale is back with a fresh twist: Strawberry Shortcake.
Nightingale’s cult-favorite ice cream sandwiches have returned to Costco, now featuring a new Strawberry Shortcake flavor with strawberry ice cream and brown sugar cookies. Image source: @costco.so.obsessed / Instagram.
Imagine this—luscious, creamy strawberry ice cream (made with real berries!) sandwiched between two soft, brown sugar cookies. It’s a nostalgic nod to the classic dessert, but with a gourmet upgrade that only Nightingale can deliver.
What Makes Nightingale So Special?
Let’s be honest: the freezer aisle is packed with ice cream sandwiches, but Nightingale stands out for a reason. Here’s why these treats have earned their cult status:
- Premium Ingredients: Nightingale uses 14% butterfat ice cream, which means every bite is extra creamy and rich. No icy, bland filling here!
- Freshly Baked Cookies: Each sandwich features cookies baked from scratch, not the cardboard-like wafers you might remember from childhood.
- Quality Mix-Ins: Whether it’s real strawberries or decadent chocolate chips, Nightingale doesn’t skimp on the good stuff.
- Chomp-Sized Convenience: The Costco-exclusive boxes come with 18 mini sandwiches—perfect for sharing at family gatherings, picnics, or just stashing away for your own secret stash.
A Deal That’s Hard to Beat
Let’s talk numbers. At $19.99 for a box of 18, you’re looking at just over a dollar per sandwich.
Compare that to the four-packs sold at other retailers for $7–$9, and it’s clear: Costco is the place to stock up. (And let’s be honest, when it comes to ice cream sandwiches, more is always better.)
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DG3YtqYJ9TQ/
Source: @costcofoodreviews / Instagram.
Source: @costcofoodreviews / Instagram.
Where Can You Find Them?
Here’s the catch—these Strawberry Shortcake sandwiches are currently only available at Costco locations in the Northeast, from Virginia to Maine.
If you’re lucky enough to live in this region, consider this your sign to make a Costco run ASAP.
Also read: The $6 find shoppers say they could eat by the spoonful—and it’s back on shelves
For everyone else, Nightingale is encouraging fans to tag their local Costco on social media and demand these treats make their way nationwide. Power to the people!
Not in the Northeast? Don’t despair. Nightingale’s website can help you track down their other flavors—like Miso Churro, Banana Pudding, Key Lime Pie, and Chocolate French Toast—at retailers near you.
And who knows? With enough demand, maybe Strawberry Shortcake will make a national debut.
Source: @checkoutvick / Tiktok.
What the Fans Are Saying
The buzz is real. One social media reviewer gave the new Strawberry Shortcake sandwiches a perfect “10 out of 10,” raving about the soft, chewy cookies and the fresh, fruity ice cream.
Online reviews echo the sentiment—these aren’t your average ice cream sandwiches. They’re a step above, and the perfect way to treat yourself (or your grandkids) this summer.
Read next: What’s back at Trader Joe’s this summer? Limited-time treats await
Have you tried Nightingale’s new Strawberry Shortcake ice cream sandwiches? Are you a die-hard fan of the Cookie Monster flavor, or do you have another favorite? Maybe you have a cherished memory of ice cream sandwiches from your own childhood—or a secret tip for making them even better.
We want to hear from you! Share your thoughts, reviews, and ice cream sandwich stories in the comments below!
