Guests stunned by shocking pricey mistake at The Plaza Hotel!
By
Aubrey Razon
- Replies 0
Imagine stepping into the luxurious Plaza Hotel, where history and grandeur meet. A stay here promises an unforgettable experience, but one mistake could cost you big.
Could a simple room service order really set you back that much?
Two friends, Amira Harvey and Jenna Sinatra, found themselves in a sticky situation that was more shocking than sweet.
During their stay at the iconic Plaza Hotel, they decided to indulge in a bit of movie magic by ordering the hotel's famous ice cream sundae, a decadent treat featured in the beloved Christmas film Home Alone 2.

However, their excitement quickly turned to disbelief when they discovered the cost of their cinematic splurge—a whopping $500!
The moment of truth was captured on video as Jenna signed the check, her expression one of pure astonishment.
“She said it was $100, it'll be fine when we split,” Jenna recounted, only to be corrected by the staggering reality of the bill.
The Plaza's luxurious dessert boasts 16 scoops of ice cream, a mountain of whipped cream, maraschino cherries, M&Ms, brownie bits, and a generous drizzle of chocolate, caramel, and raspberry sauce.
But to the dismay of Amira and Jenna, their half-a-grand treat came with just two flavors—chocolate and vanilla.
Amira, who hadn't even seen the movie that inspired their order, remarked that it wasn't the best ice cream she'd ever tasted.
Commenters on social media were quick to express their amusement and horror at the costly mistake.
“So you're telling me that you paid $31.25 for just one scoop??? That's insane,” one viewer calculated.
Others lamented the lack of variety in flavors, and some humorously pointed out the sheer volume of ice cream one could purchase with $500.
The Plaza Hotel is no stranger to film buffs and holiday enthusiasts.
Its opulent decor and festive ambiance make it a year-round attraction, with the hotel even offering a Home Alone experience package.
This themed stay includes perks like a limousine ride, a large cheese pizza, and, of course, the infamous “Home Alone Sundae.”
While the hotel's gold and red interiors remain largely unchanged since its Hollywood debut, guests should be wary of the allure of living like a movie star.
The price tag attached to these experiences can be as grand as the hotel itself.
For those of us who dream of the Plaza but prefer not to spend a small treasure on dessert, here are some tips to enjoy luxury without the financial fright:
1. Research Before You Indulge
Always check the prices before ordering room service or dining at the hotel's restaurants. A quick look at the menu can prevent a costly surprise.
2. Set a Budget
Decide on a spending limit for hotel extras. Whether it's room service, spa treatments, or souvenirs, knowing your budget can help you enjoy the luxury responsibly.
3. Look for Deals
Hotels often offer packages or special deals that can include meals, amenities, or experiences at a reduced rate. Keep an eye out for these bargains when booking your stay.
4. Share the Experience
If you're traveling with friends or family, consider sharing the cost of these unique experiences. Just make sure everyone is on the same page about the price beforehand!
5. Savor the Atmosphere
Sometimes, the luxury of a hotel like the Plaza can be enjoyed simply by being there. Take in the ambiance, explore the historic halls, and create memories without the need for extravagant spending.
Remember, a little bit of planning and awareness can go a long way in ensuring your hotel stay is both memorable and affordable. Let's indulge in the finer things in life—wisely.
Have you ever experienced sticker shock at a hotel? Do you have any tips for enjoying luxury without the lavish expense? Share your stories and advice in the comments below.
Let's help each other make the most of our travels, with all the splendor and none of the surprise bills!
Could a simple room service order really set you back that much?
Two friends, Amira Harvey and Jenna Sinatra, found themselves in a sticky situation that was more shocking than sweet.
During their stay at the iconic Plaza Hotel, they decided to indulge in a bit of movie magic by ordering the hotel's famous ice cream sundae, a decadent treat featured in the beloved Christmas film Home Alone 2.

Two guests at the Plaza Hotel were shocked to discover the cost of the famous sundae. Image sources: The Plaza Hotel/Instagram (left photo) and @amiraharvey/TikTok (right photo).
However, their excitement quickly turned to disbelief when they discovered the cost of their cinematic splurge—a whopping $500!
The moment of truth was captured on video as Jenna signed the check, her expression one of pure astonishment.
“She said it was $100, it'll be fine when we split,” Jenna recounted, only to be corrected by the staggering reality of the bill.
The Plaza's luxurious dessert boasts 16 scoops of ice cream, a mountain of whipped cream, maraschino cherries, M&Ms, brownie bits, and a generous drizzle of chocolate, caramel, and raspberry sauce.
But to the dismay of Amira and Jenna, their half-a-grand treat came with just two flavors—chocolate and vanilla.
Amira, who hadn't even seen the movie that inspired their order, remarked that it wasn't the best ice cream she'd ever tasted.
Commenters on social media were quick to express their amusement and horror at the costly mistake.
“So you're telling me that you paid $31.25 for just one scoop??? That's insane,” one viewer calculated.
Others lamented the lack of variety in flavors, and some humorously pointed out the sheer volume of ice cream one could purchase with $500.
The Plaza Hotel is no stranger to film buffs and holiday enthusiasts.
Its opulent decor and festive ambiance make it a year-round attraction, with the hotel even offering a Home Alone experience package.
This themed stay includes perks like a limousine ride, a large cheese pizza, and, of course, the infamous “Home Alone Sundae.”
While the hotel's gold and red interiors remain largely unchanged since its Hollywood debut, guests should be wary of the allure of living like a movie star.
The price tag attached to these experiences can be as grand as the hotel itself.
For those of us who dream of the Plaza but prefer not to spend a small treasure on dessert, here are some tips to enjoy luxury without the financial fright:
1. Research Before You Indulge
Always check the prices before ordering room service or dining at the hotel's restaurants. A quick look at the menu can prevent a costly surprise.
2. Set a Budget
Decide on a spending limit for hotel extras. Whether it's room service, spa treatments, or souvenirs, knowing your budget can help you enjoy the luxury responsibly.
3. Look for Deals
Hotels often offer packages or special deals that can include meals, amenities, or experiences at a reduced rate. Keep an eye out for these bargains when booking your stay.
4. Share the Experience
If you're traveling with friends or family, consider sharing the cost of these unique experiences. Just make sure everyone is on the same page about the price beforehand!
5. Savor the Atmosphere
Sometimes, the luxury of a hotel like the Plaza can be enjoyed simply by being there. Take in the ambiance, explore the historic halls, and create memories without the need for extravagant spending.
Remember, a little bit of planning and awareness can go a long way in ensuring your hotel stay is both memorable and affordable. Let's indulge in the finer things in life—wisely.
Key Takeaways
- Two guests at the Plaza Hotel were shocked to discover the cost of the famous sundae they ordered was $500.
- The sundae, inspired by a scene from Home Alone 2, consisted of an assortment of 16 ice cream scoops and other toppings, but only came in two flavours.
- Despite the high price, the guests felt that the ice cream was not worth $500, with one even saying it wasn't the best she'd ever had.
- The extravagant cost of the dessert led to amused and horrified reactions from commenters online, with some calculating the cost per scoop and others deeming it a robbery.
Let's help each other make the most of our travels, with all the splendor and none of the surprise bills!