Think twice before returning money on Venmo—how a $500 error could happen to anyone!

In today’s world of instant digital payments, apps like Venmo make money transfers incredibly easy. But with convenience comes the risk of scams, and one woman’s costly mistake is a warning for us all.

Could this be a scam you could fall victim to?


Julisa Pena, a social media user with a significant following, shared a story that resonated with many.

She woke up to a Venmo notification showing she had received $500 from a stranger.

While the unexpected windfall seemed like a blessing, the sender's immediate request for a refund raised red flags.

Despite her better judgment, Pena returned the money, hoping for honesty or perhaps even a reward for her good deed.

Instead, she was met with silence.


Screenshot 2025-01-15 at 12.33.06.png
Commenters on social media warned her that the transaction might be part of a common Venmo scam. Image source: @julisapenaa/TikTok.


The community response was swift and clear: Pena had likely fallen victim to a classic Venmo scam.

Seasoned internet users flooded her comments with advice, suggesting that she should have let the sender deal with the mistake through Venmo's official channels.

Others shared their own stories of honest mistakes and the kindness of strangers who returned misdirected funds.

But how does this scam work?


It's a modern twist on an old trick.

A scammer uses stolen credit card information to send money to an unsuspecting recipient.

When the recipient sends the money back, the scammer quickly transfers it to another account.

Once the credit card theft is discovered, the transaction is reversed, and the recipient—having sent their own money back—is left out of pocket.


Source: @julisapenaa/TikTok.


Pena, after being alerted by her followers, contacted Venmo customer service.

She learned that the scammer had immediately sent the $500 to another account with her name, a detail that made her hopeful she hadn't been scammed.

However, the risk of losing her own funds still loomed.


So, what can you do to protect yourself from such scams? Here are some tips:

1. Be Skeptical: If you receive money from someone you don't know, question it. Scammers prey on your good intentions.

2. Contact Customer Service: Instead of acting on the request, reach out to Venmo or your payment service's support team to report the incident and ask for guidance.

3. Don't Use Your Funds: Never send money back using your own funds. If the transaction is fraudulent, you could end up paying twice.

4. Educate Yourself: Familiarize yourself with common scams. Venmo's website and other financial literacy resources offer valuable information.

5. Secure Your Accounts: Use strong, unique passwords for your financial apps and enable two-factor authentication where possible.

6. Monitor Transactions: Regularly check your accounts for any unauthorized activity and report it immediately.


Source: @julisapenaa/TikTok.


The digital world offers us incredible convenience, but it also requires us to be vigilant.

As we embrace these technologies, we must also educate ourselves and our peers about the potential pitfalls.

Remember, in the realm of digital finance, a moment of caution can save you from a world of trouble.
Key Takeaways
  • A woman received $500 on Venmo from a stranger and chose to return it, fearing it might have been a test or hoping for a reward.
  • Commenters on social media warned her that the transaction might be part of a common Venmo scam, advising not to send back accidental payments and to let the sender resolve the issue.
  • Scammers may use stolen credit card details to send money, which when reversed by the card's rightful owner could leave the recipient in debt if they have already sent the money back.
  • After contacting Venmo support, the woman was told her case was likely not a scam because the sender immediately transferred the funds to someone else with her name, but caution with such transactions is still advised.
Have you or someone you know encountered a similar situation? How did you handle it? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Americans over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, The GrayVine is all about helping you make your money go further.

The GrayVine

The GrayVine searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for over 60's. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, we're all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & Fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's America
  5. Money Saving Hacks
  6. Offtopic / Everything else
  7. News & Politics
Share With a Friend
Change Weather Zip code ×
Change Petrol Postcode×