Walmart’s bakery department has become the center of an unexpected online debate after employees revealed what happens to all those leftover cake scraps.

A Reddit thread from a longtime shopper sparked the discussion by asking whether staff are ever allowed to take the discarded pieces home.

A video showed an employee shaping a heart cake with purple frosting and tossing the cut-off scraps into a metal bowl, leaving customers wondering what becomes of the pieces. Many hoped the leftovers could be transformed into something sweet instead of wasted.


According to one Walmart bakery employee, the scraps are occasionally reused in creative ways—but only for staff.

“Sometimes if we have a lot of heart cakes and a large amount of discard for the day, management lets us crumble it up and layer it with Bavarian or strawberry filling and whipped icing and take it to the break room for everyone,” they explained.


However, they added, “I don’t think taking it home yourself would fly though.” Other employees suggested it depends on the location, but in many cases the pieces are simply thrown away.

The conversation quickly turned toward cake pops, with one shopper asking if that was their ultimate destination.

Also read: Shoppers are raving about this must-try dessert—but is it worth the hype?

The employee responded, “I’m pretty sure that’s why cake pops were invented. A lot of people make cake for cake pops but traditionally they’re made from scraps.”

Some customers were distraught, saying their “heart hurts for the cake pops that could have been.” Others pointed out that similar practices occur at competitors, where scraps are either eaten by staff, repurposed, or discarded depending on store policy.

Beyond the scraps, Walmart is a major player in the US cake industry, producing massive quantities each year.

Earlier this summer, the retailer confirmed that one out of every four cakes sold nationwide comes from Walmart, according to AP News.


Also read: Taco Bell’s newest dessert is here—and it’s just $1 for a limited time

Between May and June alone, bakery staffers decorated more than 1 million cakes, reflecting just how significant the operation is.

With customized sheet cakes serving nearly 100 people priced at just $59, the affordability and scale continue to attract shoppers.

Read next: 5 desserts to skip at Walmart—your sweet tooth will thank you!
So the next time you see a heart-shaped cake on the shelf, you might wonder where the rest of it went and whether it had a chance to become something new. Would you feel better knowing the scraps were repurposed into staff desserts or cake pops, or does it make your own “heart hurt” to think of them being tossed?