[Kat81852]

Planters peanut bars

 

[TriciaR]

Stella Doro had a small round puffy cookie, forgot name. That I loved.

Thanks for sharing that @bsa1944 ! Stella D’oro made some memorable treats. Could it have been their Anginetti cookies? They were small, round, and had a light, puffy texture — a bit like an Italian wedding cookie. They were so unique!



Have you found anything that comes close to them lately, or maybe tried baking something similar yourself? Sometimes the closest thing is a homemade version, especially when favorites like that disappear from shelves.

 

[TriciaR]

Ore Ida's cheddar hashbrowns.

Thanks for sharing @Sinda ! Those Ore-Ida cheddar hashbrowns were such a comforting, easy side — crispy, cheesy, and so hard to replace once they disappeared. Have you come across any store-bought alternatives that come close? Or maybe tried recreating them at home? It’s surprising how many discontinued favorites people still miss, even years later!

 

[TriciaR]

The.original Orange Crush in the brown bottle, Necco wafers (not together!).

Thanks for sharing that @Kitkin — what a great blast from the past! The original Orange Crush in the brown bottle had such a distinct flavor (and fizz!) — and Necco Wafers were a true old-school classic. I love that you clarified not together! Do you remember when you last had either of them? Sometimes those flavors stay with us long after they’re gone. Have you come across any modern drinks or sweets that give a similar nostalgic feel?

 

[TriciaR]

Wheat Germ Oil & Honey Shampoo. I loved the smell. View attachment 59768

Thanks for sharing that @Angelm60 ! That Wheat Germ Oil & Honey Shampoo had such a rich, natural scent — it’s amazing how a fragrance can stick in your memory for years. Have you ever found anything that comes close to that scent since? Sometimes health stores or artisan brands have similar ingredients, but it’s never quite the same, is it?

 

[TriciaR]

The one thing i miss is little packs of 5 lifesavers you would get at the bank. When Dad said "we're going to the bank" we got excited!

Thanks so much for sharing that Mzkaytee67 — what a sweet memory! It’s amazing how something as small as a 5-pack of Lifesavers could make a bank visit feel like a treat. Funny how the little things stick with us the longest. Do you remember which flavor was your favorite back then? And do banks still give out anything fun where you are now, or has that tradition completely vanished?

 

[TriciaR]

$ .17/gal gas

Thanks for sharing @San Pedro Cat Lady — that one made me do a double take! 17 cents a gallon really puts things in perspective. Those were the days, weren’t they? Do you remember what kind of car you were driving back then? And how far a few bucks could get you on a road trip?

 

[TriciaR]

Trader Joe's black bean and corn salsa!!!!

Thanks for sharing that @Scorpio1027 — Trader Joe’s Black Bean and Corn Salsa really was a fan favorite! That sweet and savory combo was hard to beat. Interestingly, Trader Joe’s does still sell something similar called Cowboy Caviar. According to them, it’s a mix of black beans, corn, onions, and red bell peppers — and it’s gluten-free, fat-free, low in sodium, and vegan. Might be worth a taste if you haven’t tried it yet! Do you think it would live up to the original, or was the old version just unbeatable?

 

[TriciaR]

Root Beer Popsickles. Can find the Banana ones

Thanks for sharing that @Arkie98 — Root Beer Popsicles were such a classic treat! There’s something about that frosty root beer flavor that really hits the spot, especially on a hot day. Funny how the banana ones are still hanging on, but the root beer ones vanished! Have you ever tried making your own with root beer and a mold? Might be a fun throwback project this summer.

 

[TriciaR]

Soup Starter.

Thanks for sharing @Erika T. ! Soup Starter was such a handy pantry staple — it made throwing together a comforting meal so quick and easy. Do you remember which kind you used most often? It’s the kind of thing that would still come in handy today, especially when you want something homemade without starting from scratch.

 

[TriciaR]

The original Clairol Herbal Essence Shampoo

Thanks for sharing that @Petey — the original Clairol Herbal Essence Shampoo is such a common favorite! That earthy, floral scent was unforgettable, and the green bottle made it feel like something straight out of a forest. Have you ever come across anything that even comes close to that scent? The newer version just doesn’t quite capture the magic of the original, does it?

 

[TriciaR]

I remember Bonomo taffy. I LOVED THAT STUFF!!! iI also remember the suckers BB BATS

Thanks for sharing @angelmimi — Bonomo taffy and BB Bats! Now that’s a sweet throwback. That chewy, stretchy taffy was such a treat, and BB Bats had that fun, old-school charm. I can still picture the wrappers! Do you remember which flavor was your favorite? It’s amazing how just thinking about those treats brings back a whole era, isn’t it?

 

[TriciaR]

Honeymaid chocolate graham crackers

Thanks for sharing that @SoccerNana — those Honey Maid chocolate graham crackers were so good! Just the right mix of crispy, chocolatey, and not too sweet. Perfect for snacking or turning into a sneaky dessert. Have you seen anything similar on shelves lately, or found a DIY version that hits the spot? Some favorites just never should’ve disappeared!

 

[TriciaR]

Chocolate wafers to make ice box cake

Thanks for sharing @Honeybuns — those classic chocolate wafers were essential for a good icebox cake! Light, crisp, and perfect for layering with whipped cream. It’s such a simple dessert, but so many memories are tied to it. Have you found a decent substitute for those wafers lately? I know some people try using thin chocolate cookies, but it’s just not quite the same, is it?

 

[TriciaR]

It was a simple piece of candy that I was crazy about. I don’t remember the name of it but it was a sour lemon oval shape with ascorbic acid inside. It wasn’t overly tart but that center part would tweak my jaws with the sourness! It was sold in bulk by a Farrohs Candy Co. in the burbs of Cleveland Ohio. I haven’t been able to find any in the many states that I’ve been through or lived in.

Thanks for sharing that @Gayle B. — what a vivid memory! A sour lemon, oval candy with ascorbic acid in the center definitely sounds unique. I couldn’t find a specific match for Farrohs Candy Co., but I found something called Lemonheads—small, round sour‑sweet candies with a hard outer shell and a softer core, produced by Ferrara Candy Company. They were oval-ish, had that sharp lemon flavor, and many describe a center that packs a punch. Could that be what you remember, or do you think your candy had a different shape or texture?

 

[TriciaR]

When I was fresh out of high school, I went to work for AT&T as an “Information Operator”. I was replaced by the Internet but no one replaced the ability to call and get someone’s number and have a cheery conversation and get details like “ that’s the third house on Pine” along with the number!

Thanks so much for sharing that @CSChapman — what a lovely memory! There was something truly personal and comforting about calling an operator and getting not just information, but a friendly voice and even a little local knowledge like “third house on Pine.” It’s a kind of service the internet just can’t replicate. Do you ever find yourself missing those kinds of small, everyday interactions? Or maybe bump into moments now where a real person would make all the difference?

 

[TriciaR]

The product I would most like to see on store shelves again is yellow mustard in a jar! That squeeze stuff just doesn't taste as good and is very inconvenient.

Thanks for sharing — and I couldn’t agree more! There really is a difference between mustard in a jar and the squeeze kind. Somehow the flavor just isn’t the same, and don’t even get me started on trying to get the last bit out of a squeeze bottle! Do you remember a particular brand you used to buy? And have you ever spotted jarred mustard anywhere recently — maybe in a specialty or deli section?

 

[TriciaR]

99 cent eggs!

Thanks for sharing @Saltymermaid3* — 99 cent eggs! Now that’s a memory that hits home. It’s wild how something so basic has become such a luxury over the years. Do you remember when you first noticed the price jump? And what other grocery staples do you wish still had their old price tags?

 

[TriciaR]

Janitor in a Drum.

Thanks for sharing @Madcats — Janitor in a Drum was a cleaning classic! Tough on grime and had that “serious clean” smell. It definitely left its mark (by removing marks!). Do you remember what you used it for most — floors, laundry, everything? And have you found anything today that even comes close to how well it worked?

 

[TriciaR]

Planters peanut bars

Thanks for sharing @Kat81852 — Planters Peanut Bars were such a great snack! Crunchy, salty-sweet, and so satisfying without being over the top. They were perfect for keeping in your bag or glovebox for a little pick-me-up. Do you remember where you used to buy them most often? And have you come across any peanut bars these days that come close to the original?