The star-spangled blunder: Broadway star’s national anthem performance leaves fans divided

There’s something undeniably moving about hearing "The Star-Spangled Banner" before a big game—a moment of unity, pride, and tradition.

So when Broadway star Betsy Wolfe stepped up to the mic at Yankee Stadium for Opening Day, fans expected a powerful performance.

Instead, what unfolded left the crowd stunned and sparked a heated conversation across social media.


Wolfe, a Tony-nominated actress known for her roles in "Waitress," "& Juliet," and "Falsettos," is no stranger to the stage.

But as she sang the anthem, something seemed off—and fans didn’t hold back in their reactions.


Screenshot 2025-03-27 at 8.11.47 PM.png
Betsy Wolfe, a Broadway actress, faces criticism after her national anthem performance at Yankee Stadium. Image Source: YouTube /
& Juliet Broadway.


A Performance That Had Everyone Talking​


As soon as Wolfe began, murmurs rippled through the crowd.

By the time she finished, social media was buzzing with opinions.

Some listeners felt the performance lacked the usual confidence and precision expected from a seasoned performer.


But what really caught people’s attention? A moment where she appeared to glance at her phone mid-song.

Speculation spread quickly. Was she checking the lyrics? Did nerves get the best of her?

For many, the idea of needing a prompt for such a well-known anthem struck a sour note.



Also read: Singing us softly to goodbye—remembering a legendary voice

The Reaction and the Bigger Picture​


The backlash came swiftly, with comparisons to past anthem performances that didn’t go as planned.

While some fans expressed disappointment, others took a more understanding approach, acknowledging that even the best performers can have off days.

Despite the controversy, the Yankees secured a 4-2 win against the Milwaukee Brewers, but the conversation surrounding Wolfe’s performance continued long after the final pitch.


Source: X / YES Network.​


Following the event, Wolfe shared moments from her day on social media, focusing on the excitement of the occasion.

But for many, the discussion had already shifted from her impressive Broadway career to this unexpected anthem moment, sparking debates on performance expectations and public scrutiny.

While some defended her, others questioned how such a seasoned performer could stumble on such a widely known song.


Screenshot 2025-03-27 at 8.29.45 PM.png
Betsy Wolfe shares her excitement about the event on social media, focusing on the special moments of the day. Image Source: Instagram / bwolfepack.


Here at The GrayVine, we believe in appreciating the talent and effort that goes into any performance—while also recognizing that nobody is perfect.

This situation is a reminder of how quickly opinions form in today’s digital world and the impact public scrutiny can have on anyone, no matter how experienced.

Read next: The execution method few expected: What’s about to happen to this inmate in South Carolina

Key Takeaways

  • Broadway actress Betsy Wolfe faced criticism for her performance of the national anthem at the New York Yankees' Opening Day game, with some fans calling it the
    "worst" ever.
  • Wolfe was seen looking at her phone during the performance, sparking speculation that she was reading the lyrics.
  • Her rendition gained attention for negative reasons, with many fans expressing embarrassment and disappointment on social media.
  • Despite the controversy over her anthem performance, the Yankees won their game against the Milwaukee Brewers with a final score of 4-2.

What do you think? Have you ever faced unexpected challenges in a high-pressure moment? How do you feel about the public’s reaction? Join the conversation in the comments below!
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Americans over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, The GrayVine is all about helping you make your money go further.

The GrayVine

The GrayVine searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for over 60's. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, we're all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & Fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's America
  5. Money Saving Hacks
  6. Offtopic / Everything else
  7. News & Politics
Share With a Friend
Change Weather Zip code ×
Change Petrol Postcode×